
Buying a business is a commonly used, although not legal, concept that is usually used when talking about the acquisition of a ready-made, functioning system that brings its owners income from commercial activities.
According to the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, there are two main ways in domestic law, which, in fact, can be attributed to the methods of buying a business: the acquisition of shares in an organization or the purchase of an enterprise as a whole, as a property complex. Each of these transactions has its own characteristics and legal consequences, including in terms of obtaining rights to intellectual property (IP), if it is part of business assets.
The main difference between these transactions is that when buying shares in a company, its owner changes, but all its assets, including rights to IP objects, remain with the company itself. If the business is bought under a contract for the sale of the enterprise, then the owner of the property changes, and the buyer, among other things, receives exclusive rights to the means of individualization (commercial designation, trademark, service mark) and the rights to use them under license agreements. However, the rule on the transfer of rights to the means of individualization to the buyer is general, which means that the parties to the contract may change it depending on the purpose of acquiring the business (Clause 2, Article 559 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation).
Sometimes the purchase of a business is also understood as the acquisition of an already proven model of doing business under the auspices of a well-known brand on the basis of a franchise agreement (Article 1027 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). More information about a franchise agreement and the specifics of its conclusion can be found in the article "How to make money on a trademark".
Thus, the choice of the method of buying a business that includes IP objects depends on the purposes and how the use of specific IP objects is intended, if it is on them that profit depends.
As a rule, before buying a business that includes IP objects, IP due diligence is carried out - a comprehensive legal check (audit) of the intellectual property of the seller company. The purpose of such a check is to make sure that the IP objects really belong to the seller and are transferred to the buyer without hidden restrictions, and do not create risks (claims) from third parties.
Such an audit helps to identify legal defects even before the conclusion of the transaction and either eliminate them by drawing up the appropriate documentation, etc., or abandon distressed assets and/or reduce the price of the transaction.
As a rule, the check is divided into several stages: first, a register of all IP objects on which the business depends is compiled, and secondly, it is checked that the seller can dispose of the rights to these objects to the extent necessary for the purchase. Next, the presence of current obligations to counterparties (under license agreements, etc.), the presence of encumbrances (pledge of exclusive rights), as well as claims of third parties, including potential disputes, is checked.
Next, we will talk about the main stage: how to make sure that as a result of the transaction, the buyer will be able to obtain exclusive rights to IP objects.
The basic methods of verifying rights to IP assets differ depending on which group they belong to: to a group of objects, the exclusive rights to which arise from the moment of state registration, or to objects, the rights to which arise independently of it.
To begin with, let's consider the main ways to check IP objects, the rights to which arise as a result of state registration, in particular, trademarks and service marks.
The exclusive right to these objects is certified by a certificate for a trademark (service mark), which since 2021 has been issued in the form of an electronic document, and, if the right holder wishes, in paper form (Clause 1 of Article 1504 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). Information about the seller's rights to a trademark must be confirmed by checking with the open state register of trademarks, which contains up-to-date information about the right holder, the validity period of the trademark, the list of goods in respect of which it is registered, etc.
In addition, it is necessary to make sure that the right holder has not interrupted the use of the trademark for a period of more than three years. It is possible to confirm both the direct use of the mark by the right holder (production, advertising, sale of goods marked with the mark, etc.) and the use of the mark by third parties on the basis of an agreement (licensing, franchising, etc.). Confirmation of use will help to avoid a dispute on the early termination of trademark protection on the basis of Article 1486 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.
Objects of patent rights are inventions, utility models and industrial designs: the exclusive right to these objects is certified by a patent, which is also issued in the form of an electronic document, but can also be issued on paper at the request of the applicant (Article 1354, Clause 1 of Article 1393 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). Information about such an IP object, including its name, claims (for an invention and utility model), a set of essential features (for an industrial design), the patent owner, the validity period of the patent, etc., must also be checked against the data of the relevant state register.
Now let's move on to IP objects, the emergence of exclusive rights to which does not depend on state registration or depositing, but occurs due to the creation of the object. It should be noted right away that in relation to such objects, it is important to track the entire chain of rights, from the moment of creation of the object to the emergence of the seller's rights.
So, the objects, the rights to which arise regardless of registration, include:
They are equated to objects of copyright, so the exclusive right to them arises by virtue of the creation of the object. At the same time, the right holder, at his own discretion, can register a program (database) in a specialized state register and obtain the appropriate certificate in electronic form, and if desired, in paper form (Article 1262 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). However, since such registration is declarative, the information specified in the Register of Computer Programs or in the Register of Databases is considered reliable, unless proven otherwise.
For the buyer, this means that the information specified in the register confirms the status of the seller as the copyright holder, but does not remove the risk of its challenge. To eliminate this risk, it is necessary to check all the documentation on the basis of which the seller received the exclusive rights to the computer program or database.
For example, these can be:
If the seller has received exclusive rights to a computer program or database as a result of its purchase or other transaction, then, in addition to the documents confirming this transaction, it is necessary to check whether the program (database) was registered in the register before the transaction under which the exclusive rights were transferred to the seller. This is due to the fact that the fact of the transfer of the exclusive right to a registered program is subject to state registration (Article 1262 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). Otherwise, the transfer of such right is considered invalid; accordingly, the seller has no right to dispose of it.
Such objects include literary and scientific works, musical and audiovisual works, works of fine art and design, photographs, etc.
Such copyright objects can be voluntarily deposited, i.e., a copy of the object can be deposited in a specialized depository and receive the appropriate certificate. However, deposition does not establish an unconditional presumption of authorship, but only fixes the date of transfer, the content of the object, and a particular applicant. In order to eliminate the risk of challenging the status of the copyright holder, it is necessary to check the availability of documents that confirm the fact of creation of the work by a specific person (source materials, metadata, order agreements, etc.).
Separately, it is necessary to check the availability of rights to official IP objects that are created by the employee in connection with the performance of his job duties or a specific task of the employer. At the same time, the status of official objects can be both objects, the rights to which arise as a result of registration, and objects, the rights to which arise independently of it.
As a general rule, exclusive rights to official objects arise with the employer (Clause 2 of Article 1295, Clause 3 of Article 1370 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). However, the parties have the right to change this condition, so it is necessary to check whether the contract with the employee contains a condition that the exclusive right to the IP object remains with him. In this case, the employer can use the IP object under the terms of a simple (non-exclusive) license and transfer only this right to another person.
In practice, a set of documents is usually checked, which includes: an employment contract, a job description, an employer's assignment, and an acceptance certificate of the created object. At the same time, in order to recognize an object as an employee, it is not required that the employment contract, job description, or other document defining the employee's job duties indicate the performance of work on the creation or processing (improvement) of specific objects.
In addition, you need to check the availability of documents that confirm that the employer has performed any of the following actions within a certain period:
The term for performing these actions depends on the type of object:
Without appropriate evidence, there is a risk that the employer has lost the exclusive right to the IP object, since it has returned to the employee by virtue of a direct provision of the law.
In conclusion, it should be noted that, according to the Federal Tax Service of Russia, in recent years there has been an increase in the volume of intangible assets (rights to IP objects) on the balance sheets of organizations, and such objects themselves are often the main strategic business assets. In modern realities, the purchase of a business with strong intellectual property can quickly lead to commercial success. The main thing is to make sure in a timely manner that, as a result of the transaction, the buyer will be able to obtain the necessary rights in the required amount.
Need help with a trademark?
We can help you:
— Develop and register a trademark;
— Draft a trademark license agreement;
— Arrange the assignment of exclusive rights;
— Draft a commercial concession agreement;
— Protect your trademark against infringement.